Steve, You know how to read 'dial' calipers?!?!?!
Most guys do not even know what you are talking about any more unless it has an on and off button
I still use my Starrett mics and calipers at home and at work. Only thing is that I have been using Mitutoyu digital calipers more and more lately. Getting lazy in my old age
Whatever you decide to buy is up to you. Both types are OK. It just depends upon what you get use to.